The Great Debate Credit Card Or Debit Cards

The Great Debate: Credit Card Or Debit Card

The Great Debate Credit Card Or Debit Cards
The Great Debate Credit Card Or Debit Cards

I have never owned a credit card. Despite credit card companies having great promotions, I felt that it was simply a gimmick to go down the slippery slope. I personally saw how close friends (educated poor) raked up over tens of thousands of debts because of these shiny cards. My Telegram channel where I share one financial tip a day also know I shut this off totally.

Until 2021, this year I applied for my first credit card while doing research on how to save on big ticket purchases.

So what changed? I want to share a new perspective of what I learnt this year and hope this can somehow change your news on these cards in our wallets.

What is a Credit or Debit Card?

Both credit and debit cards have made it easier and more convenient to do purchases whether it is online of in stores. There is one key difference.

Credit Cards: It allows you to borrow money from the card issuer up to a certain limit to purchase an item or withdraw cash.

Debit Cards: It allows you to draw money that you have deposited in the bank.

Basically, credit card uses other people’s money and a debit card uses your money.

I want to draw on 3 points for you to consider before you make a decision for yourself.

#1: Responsibility

Do you have spending issues? Trust me, I met people who have and they were the ones who encouraged me to write The Ultimate 4 Quadrants Shopping Guide. They have been using it like a bible since then. I do think it is important to know and accept what kind person we are. It is only with this knowledge and acceptance that can allow us to create a solution for you.

Often, I see people who denies or dismiss their true self makes their debts even worse.

For people who have spending issues, get a Debit Card.

#2: Benefits

If you are well disciplined with your finances, you may explore what benefits Credit Cards have. Some offers cashbacks while others offers miles. Some might give you a luggage or even upfront cash when you sign up! This is quite straight-forward.

It is a hands down win for Credit Card here. The only thing you have to make sure is to pay it all up before your interest comes in.

#3: Security

I truly appreciate this a few years ago when I received an SMS from OCBC saying that $3000 has been deducted from my debit card. This message was received when I was in office attending a training and I don’t have any transaction of that size. I logged into to my OCBC account to verify and indeed the amount was deducted. To tell you the truth, I felt nausea when I received the sms.

I have long lost that SMS but I have found something similar from Stomp.

The Great Debate Credit Card Or Debit Cards Security
The Great Debate Credit Card Or Debit Cards Security

I immediately dialed for OCBC. For what felt like decades (for those of you who have called the bank before, you would know how long it took), a customer service representative replied. I appreciated the representative was clear and calm. He advised some paperwork, asked me to dispose of my current debit card and arranged a new one to arrive in a few working days.

However, he was hesitant when I asked when I will receive the $3000 back. He mentioned the bank will do the appropriate investigation and will take a few weeks before the amount will be back in my bank again.

Eventually, I did get my $3000 back in my account. It took slightly lesser than 2 weeks. However, I felt worried all the time.

Credit cards on the other hand, serves as a border between your personal money and the transaction. In an event of an identify theft or stolen card, it will be less stressful as it is technically not your money. I never truly appreciated the value of Credit cards until this happened.

Final Thoughts

I have 1 credit card which I used mainly for my transactions. I reap some benefits by getting cashbacks from my transaction and yes, I do make sure I pay on time.

Which will you choose? Credit cards or debit cards? Let me know in the comments below.

Chengkok is a licensed Financial Services Consultant since 2012. He is an Investment and Critical Illness Specialist. Wealthdojo was created in 2019 to educate and debunk “free financial advice” that was given without context.  

Feel Free To Reach Out To Share Your Thoughts.

Contact: 94316449 (Whatsapp) chengkokoh@gmail.com (Email)
Telegram: Wealthdojo [Continuous Learning Channel]
Reviews: About Me

The views and opinions expressed in this publication are those of the author and do not reflect the official policy or position of any other agency, organisation, employer or company. Assumptions made in the analysis are not reflective of the position of any entity other than the author.

Maximise your Credit Card Miles and Cashback Using Cardup Singe

Maximise your Credit Card Miles and Cashback Using Cardup

I thought I had a conclusion deciding between Cashback or Airmiles when using a credit card. However, the existence of CardUp might change the entire equation all together.

[If it matters, this is not a sponsored post.]
Maximise your Credit Card Miles and Cashback Using Cardup Mainpage
Maximise your Credit Card Miles and Cashback Using Cardup Mainpage

 

What is CardUp?

CardUp is a platform that enables payment and collection of big expenses using existing credit cards, in places where cards are not accepted today. Example of such expenses includes rent, income taxes, educational loan, insurance (usually points are not applicable for insurance) etc. CardUp allows you to use credit cards to pay for those bills.

One of my friends shared with me that he had to PayLah his landlord his monthly rental of $1000. Unfortunately, most landlords do not accept credit cards. $1000/month is a big expenditure and if he is able to use a credit card, he might be able to collect cashback or airmiles along the way.

 

How does CardUp work?

Basically, CardUp acts like a middleman. You pay CardUp via credit card, CardUp will pay your vendor/suppliers/landlord for you.

In doing so, you get to collect cashback or airmiles which will otherwise be lost if you make a normal bank transfer. CardUp is currently a plug and play system. Simply sign up for an account, enter the details of your preferred credit card/s and you can start to  make and schedule payments.

CardUp will take a processing fee of between 2.25% to 3.3% for that transaction. Typically, it will take around 3 business days for your recipient to get the money. However, if you need a next day transaction, an additional 0.3% fee applies.

Currently, CardUp is able to perform transaction for the following.

  1. Rental payments (to a landlord)
  2. Rental deposits (to a landlord)
  3. Condominium Maintenance Fees (to a MCST or property developer)
  4. Tuition/School fees (to Singapore based schools or education centres)
  5. Insurance Premiums
  6. Income Tax/Property Tax/Corporate Tax/GST/Stamp Duty
  7. Season Parking
  8. Car Loans
  9. Electricity
  10. Helper Salary
  11. Miscellaneous Payments
  12. Payroll
  13. Supplier invoices

I believe CardUp will expand their services in the years to come. I have bold a couple of expenses in bold because I believe those are the more general expenses that everyone will pay. We will be using it to illustrate whether it is worth it to use CardUp or not.

 

Is it worth it to use CardUp?

We have to set a few assumptions and context to see if it is worth it. In my previous article on whether you can afford cancer, a typical medium income in Singapore is $56,550. I will draw a few assumptions from this income.

Example #1: Eric (Single. Stays with parents. Pays some of the household bills)

Maximise your Credit Card Miles and Cashback Using Cardup Singe
Maximise your Credit Card Miles and Cashback Using Cardup Single

Eric is working as a marketing executive in a SME. His annual income is $60,000. His annual income tax is $1950 (we are assuming he do not have any other income nor reliefs). He lives with his parents in a 4 room HDB flat and is paying for the electric bills (Annual Electricity Bills: $1608. Source:Average monthly electricity bill of a 4-room HDB household). He pays around $9000 annually to an insurance company.

Total Annual Recurring Bills: $12,558 (or $1046.50/month)

Maximise your Credit Card Miles and Cashback Using Cardup UOB ONE CARD
Maximise your Credit Card Miles and Cashback Using Cardup UOB ONE CARD

As you can see in the above screenshot, Eric will have gotten a net saving of $130.

 

Maximise your Credit Card Miles and Cashback Using Cardup UOB PRVI MILES VISA CARD
Maximise your Credit Card Miles and Cashback Using Cardup UOB PRVI MILES VISA CARD

If Eric were to choose miles, he will have 17,178 Airmiles which he can use to change for an airticket once he have accumulated enough. (I’m putting $12,000 into income tax for simplified illustration purposes only)

 

Example #2: Joseph (Married with one child. Bought a house with wife. Pays some of the household bills)

Maximise your Credit Card Miles and Cashback Using Cardup Married
Maximise your Credit Card Miles and Cashback Using Cardup: Married

Joseph is working as a teacher. His annual income is $60,000. His annual income tax is $1950 (we are assuming he do not have any other income and excluding reliefs). He lives with his wife in a 4 room HDB flat and is paying for the electric bills (Annual Electricity Bills: $1608. Source:Average monthly electricity bill of a 4-room HDB household). He pays around $9000 annually to an insurance company. He also pays for his son’s childcare fees of $800/month (Annual: $9600). He also pays for the helper of $700/month (Annual: $8400).

Total Annual Recurring Bills: $30,558 (or $2546.50/month)

Maximise your Credit Card Miles and Cashback Using Cardup Cashback Example 2
Maximise your Credit Card Miles and Cashback Using Cardup Cashback Example 2

As you can see in the above screenshot, Jospeh will have gotten a net saving of $660.

 

Maximise your Credit Card Miles and Cashback Using Cardup Airmiles Example 2
Maximise your Credit Card Miles and Cashback Using Cardup Airmiles Example 2

If Joseph were to choose miles, he will have 42,945 Airmiles which he can use to change for a Business Class Airticket to Bali worth $1,154. His flight savings is $557. (I’m putting $30,000 into income tax for simplified illustration purposes only)

 

Conclusion

If the recurring bill amount is smaller, cashback might be the preferred option as you probably have to wait another full year to get enough airmiles to fly. However, if the recurring bill is larger, you might be slightly indifferent towards airmiles or cashbacks.

In whichever your preference, CardUp will help you collect cashback or airmiles which will otherwise be lost if you make a normal bank transfer.

Some last words of advice: CardUp dependent on the bank’s credit card benefits. Any change in the rules of credit card benefits / airmiles redemption will affect the calculation as of above. We are writing in the view of a personal finance perspective. We recognize there might be other cashflow benefits for businesses to use CardUp. The information is update on 12 Aug 2020.

 

 

 

No one will care about your money as much as you do.

In Wealth Management, it is important to Pay yourself first. Beware of scams. Before you invest in any company or popular investment opportunity, be sure to do your own due diligence. If you wish to learn more about investment, I hope to nurture genuine relationships with all of my readers.

Check out my most popular blog post in 2020 so far: 5 mistakes people make using their CPF.

Please feel free to contact me on my Instagram (@chengkokoh) or Facebook Page or my Telegram Channel! Or subscribe to our newsletter now!